The Graveyard Book by Neil Gaiman

Reviewed by Dave Caddy.

I loved this book. But once again, this was recommended as a Year 3 and Year 4 read.

I typed ‘What books are suitable to be read to a Year 3 class of children?’ And The Graveyard Book was recommended. How stupid! The book starts with a family being murdered – stabbed actually.

In the modern classroom, with so many anxious children, if I read a story of a family being murdered, a barrage of parent emails would follow. Also, the book is too long for a Year 3 or Year 4 child; it would take half a year to read to them.

Personally, I loved the book, but not as a read aloud to the class. I’d highly recommend it to a competent Year 6 and even a high school student.

Mr Gaiman writes so well.

The Dancing Bear by Michael Morpurgo

I immediately thought it would be a book about bears forced to dance. Instead it is a gentle tale of the love between a young girl and a bear. The whole book is about their relationship. It might represent commercialism/wealth/ money and the new ways against the old ways. In the end the new ways win, and the old ways die.

I thoroughly enjoyed the book; it is written for Years 4-6.

At the start of the book, there is mention of the girl’s bitter old grandfather who sometimes hits her… but this is such a small part of the story.

It is quite a short story – about 16000-17000 words long and can be read in an hour or two.

Mayday by Nelson DeMille and Thomas Block

This is NOT a children’s book. It is an old adult book, published in 1998 and reprinted in 2006.

I am enjoying the book, although parts of it seemed contrived. A passenger plane is crippled by a test missile from the navy. A plane load of passengers become zombies when their brains are deprived of oxygen. A part time pilot must land the plane. Air traffic control give false co-ordinates and instructions with the hope that the plane will crash and everyone will die -resulting in less insurance payout.

Anyway, with crazy zombie-like passengers trying to get into the cockpit, the plane running out of fuel, poor and unreliable communication from the control tower, the navy realising their mistake and wanting the plane shot down … it is an exciting ride.

If you want character development, realistic dialogue and plot, heart and depth, avoid this book, but if you want a fun, written for late 20th century movie, fast paced, light read… this is for you.

The Girl Who Drank the Moon by Kelly Barnhill

Winner of the Newbery Medal in 2017, this book was recommended as a possible read for Year 4 children. I think that it is more appropriate for Year 5’s and 6’s. There is no question that the book is beautifully written, nor that it holds one’s attention, yet the usual Year 4 child is not at this level of comprehension. Perhaps the length of the book is also prohibitive. Personally, I loved it, and recommend it for upper primary. (Even if the start is traumatic – tearing a baby off its screaming mother and then leaving it in the woods to be eaten by animals.)

The Book of Wondrous Possibilities by Deborah Abela

This was a Notable Book for 2023. I really tried hard to like this book and I pushed myself to read half of it … but gave up. I just found it all too difficult to believe. And the dialogue seemed contrived. Perhaps a young child who wants to be a hero will like it. Maybe!

Perhaps I am just getting a bit old and cranky! Maybe it is the lack of sleep over the last week – thanks to my son who had a party here. Or from a lack of sleep because my wife had COVID and I slept on the floor; tried to sleep on the floor.

The Bravest Word by Kate Foster

This book is about a young boy who is depressed. He rescues a dog and by finding out that it is possibly depressed, he makes the link to himself. His father is kind and understanding and also suffered depression when his father died, so is able to relate with the boy. The mother bull-dozes through life. Eventually, everyone is able to talk about depression. Even the school bully jumps on board and says he suffers from anxiety. The resolution is all a bit hard to believe… but the intention of the book is good.

The Librarian has recommended it for Year 6. I think a Year 5 would also read it. The subject matter is all a bit sad. I wouldn’t recommend it for Year 4. The language is all good but the topic of depression is so depressing. About 40,000 words long I think. It is a notable book by CBCA in 2023.

Runt by Craig Silvey

It took a fair bit to get into this book, but overall it was well worth it. (A librarian friend of mine didn’t finish it.)

I have tried to work out why I didn’t enjoy this book as much as I should have. The plot was well executed, Craig Silvey writes well, and there was even an underdog as the hero! I think my issue is that the characterization, plot, and setting were for a younger audience than the actual writing.

I did enjoy the book, especially the climax. I felt the author rushed to tie up lots of loose ends and some of this was unbelievable and perhaps unnecessary.

I recommend this book for a competent Year 4 reader because of the length.

Reviewed by David Caddy

Molly and the Twin towers – a 9/11 story by Jessika Fleck

It was a bit confusing at the start because the family that lived in a small apartment consisted of 2 girls, 2 dads and a grandmother. (Oh yes, a cat too.)

The book is well written and edited. I think children will enjoy the story, and probably both boys and girls too. At a quick guesstimate I’d say the book is about 15,000 words long. The age group I’d suggest would be Year 4 to Year 6.

It is a realistic fictional story of 9/11 that seems well researched. I recommend it.

Henry Heckelbeck Spells Trouble by Wanda Coven

Firstly, I love the author’s name.

Um! Mmm! The theme and writing is appropriate for Year 3. On page 4 the illustration cuts off some of the text. At first I thought this was a realistic fiction book, but things go a little weird in Chapter 7. I am not really sure what happened there.

I thought the book was about detectives, then magic, and then throwing a contest. The boy worked hard at learning all his spelling words and then winning was seen as selfish? I disagree with that.

This book, published by Little Simon, is disappointing. Where was the editor?

Snow Man and the Seven Ninjas – an Epic Fail Tale

I think kids will love it. Basically it is a retell of Snow White that is way more interesting! Basically, a body builder is jealous of a snowman and tries to kill him. There is a cool mirror and instead of a huntsman we have a stuntman.

I am not sure how many words there are, but there many illustrations. Every page has an illustration and a lot of pages have no text other than what accompanies the illustration.

Let’s say the book is for Year 4s. I’d say Year 3, except the vocabulary is quite difficult for many Year 3s.

Vomiting, picking noses, huge amounts of blood and mashed-up body parts. etc.

Here is a sample :

… you pathetic bacteria, scraped from the fingernail of a bottom-scratching baboon.

… you miserable drop of pond scum, squeezed from the armpit of a wart-licking toad.

…you worthless toenail clipping from a sewer-dwelling cockroach.

Bossy Flossie – The Secret to Success by Shiela Greenwald

This is a book written for Year 4 I think, but there are too many twists in it. I’d hate to write a book review on it. I got confused at the culmination of the story and had to go back in the book to find out what the children were talking about.

Having said that, it is an easy read, the dialogue is good. The content is realistic and I liked the idea of raising money for charity through a craft fair and then through selling toys.

Weirdo 10 Weird History by Anh Do

I’ve read a few of these books and the standard is always high. For the age category they are excellent. I recommend a competent Year 2 or Year 3 reader.

This book is filled with jokes about a few subjects. I think children would love playing with language, particularly jokes. This book will also motivate children to write and to play in costume boxes.

My only criticism: I found the number of stories retold to the class tedious and I skipped over some of them. Maybe there was a word count or page count that the publisher expected. I suppose there are about 5000 words… maybe?

I recommend these books.

Daisy Dreamer – The Ice Castle #5 by Holly Anna

The story started quickly. It was an exciting story for this age group. The language was perfectly pitched. The book was well edited. There are about 5000 words, maybe a little more.I think a Year 2 or Year 3 child would love it.

This series is about a young girl who has an imaginary friend who gets her into all sorts of ‘trouble’.

Birdsong by Katya Balen

A gentle story about a girl who is traumatised by a car crash, and who no longer plays the flute. She is angry and silent. Then she meets Noah and he shows her two blackbirds and their eggs. Eventually, the music finds its way back into the girl’s heart.

I enjoyed this book. It was an easy read, less than 10,000 words. Suitable for Year 4 upwards. There are a few themes I suppose: forgiveness of self and others. Never give up. Care of nature. There is music everywhere and it can be healing.

Santa Gets a Second Job by Michele D’Ignazio Ill. by Sergio Olivotti

I enjoyed this book as much for the illustrations as the story. It is not a long read – I think about 132 pages and a lot of them are full page and half page illustrations. The text is large with plenty of white space.

I am not sure of the age it was written for – probably 12 or 13 year olds; much of the humour and language is for this age group. Some of the themes are redundancies, traditionalists, love, ageist behaviours. Some of the words are disparagingly, diligent, summoned, selection process.

Poor old Santa is redundant so he applies for other jobs. Unfortunately he is not cut out for the jobs on offer – well not until the end of the book. There is also a love story here, assuming there is no Mrs Claus. Ha!

The Gumazing Gum Girl – Gum Luck (Book 2) by Rhode Montijo

I enjoyed it and wanted to keep reading. A girl stops an evil genius out to get revenge on the world. The evil genius hates gum girl and wants to get rid of her. Obviously he also wants to rob money, etc.

There were too many lessons in here about not chewing gum or you’ll get cavities. Also that you need to be honest with your parents. It is probably a Year 3/4 book. There are some Spanish /Mexican words in here – which will confuse some readers. The characters are Gomez and Rico and …

Heavily illustrated book. Maybe 6000 or more words.

Ella and Olivia – little Lifesavers by Yvette Poshoglian

I have only ever listened to kids read these and I was probably more interested in the quality of the reading rather than the content. This book was about Life Savers and I realised it was an Australian publication. The

The book is VERY simple for Year 2. Less than 3000 words. The setting is TOLD in the first couple of pages and then the story starts. The two young girls are in a surf club competition and they win it.

Anna Gain by Guy Bass

I recommend the book for Year 3 readers. It is a ‘Ground Hog Day’ type book. A young girl gets trapped in the same 60 seconds again and again. She learns that EVERY SECOND COUNTS does not refer to always being on time and never late… but it means that time is precious.

I enjoyed the book – it is about 9000 words long at a rough guess.

Rainbow Magic – Elisha the Eid fairy by Daisy Meadows

Well, I must admit I was surprised. It has been some time since I read one of these ‘little girl’ books and to read about the Eid festival was refreshing and educational. There was also mention of other fairies and festivals that the evil goblins and Jack Frost had interfered with – Deena the Diwali Fairy, Hana the Hanukkah Fairy and Bea the Buddha Day Fairy. I assume there are books about the evil way Jack Frost has interfered with these festivals.

This is probably a Year 2 and early Year 3 reader… but I must admit I was surprised.

When Breath Becomes Air by Paul Kalanithi.

This is an ADULT book about a young man dying of cancer. I found some parts difficult to read, and some parts confusing. Some of the writing was beautiful, subtle and touching. There are many medical terms, which may put off readers, but the journey is worth the effort. I agree with one review, ‘Every doctor should read this book.’

This book is highly acclaimed – a worldwide best seller.

Ninja Kid 3 by Anh Do

I have often wondered what these books were like. I assumed they were drivel because some of the bigger publishers grab a name, a marketing strategy and churn out rubbish; however, I was pleasantly surprised by the quality of this book. Full credit to the author and editors.

There were plenty of twists and turns and excitement in this early-reader book. It is perfect for children just starting to read longer books. Year 3 children and some early Year 4 readers would enjoy it.

Crossing the Divide – Phenomena by Roger Carr

I enjoyed this book. It was published in 2000, and all the references are modern. It is less than 20,000 words so is suitable for a competent Year 4 reader through to a Year 6 reader. It is a story of a young girl; however, the story would appeal to both boys and girls.

I actually thought the story was about crossing the Blue Mountains on the east coast of Australia, until mountain lions were mentioned. I was disappointed it was not Australian. Perhaps I can get the children in my class to write an Australian version.

A girl has a journal account written by her great, great, great grandfather and becomes obsessed with his own obsession to see what is on the other side of the mountain range. (Perhaps google earth could have helped here.) Anyway, she goes on an adventure with her grandfather. I would have liked the mountain lion attack to have been described in greater detail. Kids will enjoy this – it is well-written.

I hate the cover of this book – yuck!

The Ab Diver by Colin Thiele

This is a straight forward adventure story – nothing special but well written none-the-less. Pub 1988, reprinted 92. Suitable for boys and girls in years 4 to 6. Less than 30,000 words. A brother and sister get a bad horoscope and then everything bad happens to them. Almost killed in a plane crash. Almost attacked by a shark. They stumble across abalone poachers. They help save a diver who has the bends. There are some obvious parts where the author wanted to include some of his research – apart from that it is good.

AQUILA by Andrew Norriss

I enjoyed this book. It is suitable for years 4 – 6. (marketed as ages 9 – 11) The book has between 60000 and 70000 words There were a stack of old books at the back of a classroom, and some teachers were talking about possibly throwing them out. I said I’d read the books and give some feedback. First off the rank is Aquila. Two boys find an alien spaceship and slowly find out its capabilities. Realistic. Funny. Recommended. The main message is that you can do whatever you want as long as you have determination and strong support. ‘A man can fly anywhere, if he rides on the back of an eagle.’

Published 1997 – still topical (Just) with references to mobile phones and the internet.

The Good Son – a story of the First World War Told in Miniature

I loved this. I highly recommend it for upper primary and older children – adults too. All the illustrations are done using small plastic soldiers and the mood is captured beautifully. The book is really amazing. And the narrative is based upon a true story – it is so sad. I must emphasize that it is NOT for younger readers.

The Glimme by Emily Rodda and Marc McBride

The book is heavily illustrated, full of dragons, so I think kids will love it. I found the characterization quite difficult to get a handle on. I loved the illustrations. This is a fantasy story of a young boy who gets taken into another land, and his journey back to his real life. I found the actual story okay. I would recommend it for primary school children from Year 4 to Year 6.

.

The Dog Runner by Bren MacDibble

I read this quickly and I thoroughly enjoyed it. It is the story of 2 children (boy and girl depend on each other) surviving after society crumbles. This is also a story of the need to care for the environment, food security, family, strength and survival. How the land was managed prior to European settlement. Also about dogs. 2 children set off across the country in a cart pulled by dogs. It is about 40,000 words maybe. I’d highly recommend it for Year 5 to lower secondary. I enjoyed this.

Catch a Falling Star by Meg McKinlay

What a super book for Years 5 – 9. Meg writes so well. This story is about a young girl dealing with her father’s death, and the effect it has had on her little family. There is no swearing or fighting or adventure, as such, but there is the loving relationship of a sister to her younger brother, and a healthy friendship between two girls. The book is well over 50,000 words so the read is for upper primary and lower secondary kids. I have read many young adult books recently and there is so much crud printed nowadays – Meg’s book is of superior quality. I highly recommend the book.

The Secrets of Magnolia Moon by Edwina Wyatt

I think I have to read this again. My daughter will kill me for saying it but this book is definitely a ‘girl’s book’. I didn’t like it. I didn’t think it went anywhere but I know that some girls will probably love the imagery. The steps grumble. The two girls pretend they are different types of fruit. …dancing polka up the hill. Heel and toe, heel and toe.. Very lyrical writing that i didn’t like. Maybe recommended for girls in Years 3-6.

Wonder Struck by Brian Selznick

Having read his first book, I have been wanting to read this for some time. Would it be as good as his first? I don’t think so, but I still enjoyed it. The book is over 600 pages in length, but many of the pages are illustrations, so it is an easy and quick read; I read it in a day. The book is about a little deaf boy finding his place in the world. I’d recommend the book for Year 5 upwards. It has a Lexile rating of 830 so an advanced Year 4 child could read and understand it.

PLunked by Michael Northrop

This book is hard to read because there is so much baseball terminology. I persisted and I enjoyed the book, but would only recommend it to baseball fanatics. It is for 10 – 13 year old children. It is a story about a young boy who gets hit twice by pitched balls. Now he is spooked and must overcome his fear.

Caesar the war dog by Stephen Dando-Collins

I read this book on the recommendation of an advanced reader in Year 4. I enjoyed it. It is the story of a Defence forces dog in Afghanistan. It is full of facts about the Australian forces in Afghanistan. I did NOT make a connection with the dog or its owners. Loads of facts but not much emotional connection. Still, I recommend it for upper primary and lower secondary readers.

A Different Land by Paul Jennings

I liked this book. It is about 13 000 word long maybe? Quite short, but well written and quite an easy read. Maybe kids will be hooked in by the mystery! If so, they will enjoy it. There are other books in the series – A Different Dog, and A Different Boy. I’d recommend the book for Year 4 to Year 6. And probably enjoyed more by boys.

The SLeeper and the Spindle by neil gaiman illustrated by chris riddell

I read this a week ago and even though I loved it, I cannot recommend it for any reading age because I cannot remember the word count or the sentence length or the suitability of the content. There is a nice twist at the end.

This is a graphic novel for teenagers and young adults. I recommend it to them.

Little Bird Flies by Karen MccOmbie

About 60,000 words long. I loved it. The book is more of a girl’s book. Recommended to competent readers in Year 6 upwards.

It is the story of a family living on a remote, rugged and beautiful Scottish island. When the Lord of the Island dies, the family must deal with the new landowner.

The description of the island, and the characterisation is handled superbly. I highly recommend this book.

Amelia fang and The Barbaric Ball by Laura Ellen Anderson

This is probably quite a nice little book for Grade 3 children, and the advanced Grade 2 reader.

The book is heavily illustrated and the illustrations are consistent and of a high standard. The font is large and the chapters are short. In total, the book is about 15,000 words, so a beginning reader will have success.

It is a simple storyline which the kids will like. Vampires and fairies are subjects which kids enjoy. The book cover is appealing.

The mark of The Maker Stone – Book One

I did not enjoy the book and doubt many children will. Less than 30,000 words, The Mark of the Maker Stone needs work in so many areas. I tried to read this book three times, but failed.

Judging from his website, Daniel Corcoran has his heart in the right place. He has written and illustrated picture books, which may be good, and his author talks are enjoyed.

The Mark of the Maker Stone is written for Year 2 or Year 3 children, but the book is too long for this age group. I do not recommend it.

Twist of Gold by Michael MOrpurgo

Gee, Michael Morpurgo tells a good story. Twist of Gold is about 70,000 words. It is a long read for a competent reader in upper primary and high school. When their mother is close to death, two young children travel to America to find their father. On their journey they have many adventures, but never give up hope, after all, they have their family’s golden torc, which keeps them safe!

This book is highly recommended. It is too long for a Year 4 reader, or even an average Year 5 reader.

Tiny Timmy on holiday by tim cahill and julian Gray

What a disappointing book! I always recommended these simple reads to my struggling boy readers in Year 4, but not any more.

The first paragraph is present tense and the rest is past tense.

Kyah and Shae come running into the kitchen on page 13. They aren’t introduced as brothers and I don’t know which is which.

Two big questions on page 20 are both said, rather than asked, and on page 5, I laugh as Studs and Hacker might fly off!

I force myself to finish the book. Approximately the first quarter is about Timmy and his friends preparing for their holidays, saying what they are doing. None of this is revisited. The book finishes while Timmy is still on Sunshine Island.

This book will NOT improve a child’s reading. Scholastic has let itself down here. I wonder what the other books in this series are like.

Weirdo Hopping Weird 12 by Anh Do

I am not sure what to say. There are less than 2000 words in the book. There are some pages with less than 5 words on them. Huge illustrations on each page. There is a story. The books are cleverly marketed. I think these books are ideal for Year 3, and for weak Year 4 readers.

The story is so simple it would not be beneficial for Year 5 readers, even the weaker readers, except for the boast of having finished a book.